This page contains sales data by subdivision for NINE suburbs around the northern half of the Columbus metro area. The areas are Dublin, Powell, Lewis Center, southern Delaware County, Worthington, Westerville, Hilliard, New Albany and Delaware.
It’s updated monthly a few days after the end of the month. If there is a subdivision that you would like to see added to the list, let me know, and I’ll see if there are any sales so far for it.
The info in the tables includes the name of the subdivision, the number of single-family homes that were sold, then the averages for size (sq ft) and the selling price.
The data below is for Jan 1 , 2008- Oct 31, 2008
Or you can view home sales data for several Central Ohio school districts on my web site.
| Subdivision | # Homes | Sq Ft | Sold Price |
| Tartan | 29 | 5087 | $784,142 |
| Amberleigh | 10 | 4534 | $548,100 |
| Belvedere | 10 | 3642 | $438,900 |
| Bishop’s Crossing | 6 | 3695 | $411,500 |
| Muirfield | 76 | 3347 | $393,843 |
| Hawk’s Nest | 11 | 3231 | $392,500 |
| Bristol Commons | 6 | 2952 | $371,200 |
| Donegal Cliffs | 5 | 3068 | $352,000 |
| Westbury | 21 | 2875 | $330,166 |
| Wyndham | 8 | 2804 | $325,912 |
| Dublinshire | 15 | 2818 | $323,929 |
| Llewellyn Farms | 8 | 2623 | $294,300 |
| Brandon | 9 | 2539 | $288,572 |
| Hemingway | 11 | 2454 | $263,838 |
| Olde Sawmill (DSD) | 18 | 2373 | $229,480 |
| Heather Glen | 11 | 1923 | $216,863 |
| Subdivision | # Homes | Sq Ft | Sold Price |
| Wedgewood Park | 8 | 4568 | $694,762 |
| Wedgewood | 7 | 4985 | $681,500 |
| Loch Lomond | 4 | 4761 | $654,500 |
| Campden Lakes | 6 | 4354 | $584,488 |
| Deep Run/Riverbend | 4 | 3911 | $523,475 |
| Golf Village | 48 | 3210 | $367,300 |
| Rutherford Estates | 4 | 3715 | $346,828 |
| Ashmoore | 4 | 2959 | $345,875 |
| Olentangy Ridge | 18 | 2925 | $304,172 |
| Big Bear Farms | 20 | 2855 | $299,750 |
| Liberty Lakes | 3 | 2847 | $296,500 |
| Scioto Reserve (BVSD) | 21 | 2814 | $285,687 |
| Scioto Reserve (OSD) | 25 | 2764 | $283,034 |
| Lakes of Powell | 5 | 2442 | $279,580 |
| Bartholomew Run | 6 | 2862 | $280,400 |
| Grandshire | 10 | 2437 | $264,205 |
| Powell Place | 7 | 2336 | $238,078 |
| Subdivision | # Homes | Sq Ft | Sold Price |
| McCammon Chase | 5 | 4087 | $491,580 |
| Lake Shore | 6 | 3580 | $432,910 |
| Parkshore | 5 | 3223 | $386,080 |
| The Shores | 6 | 3086 | $347,636 |
| Wilshire | 15 | 2930 | $302,095 |
| Cross Creek | 7 | 2872 | $289,000 |
| Willow Springs | 5 | 2901 | $287,030 |
| Walker Woods | 17 | 2733 | $281,494 |
| Abbey Knoll | 9 | 2581 | $276,425 |
| Vill @ Alum Creek | 16 | 2766 | $276,250 |
| Glen Oak | 17 | 2495 | $258,230 |
| Bryn Mawr | 3 | 2658 | $255,033 |
| Oak Creek | 47 | 2269 | $235,363 |
| Piatt Meadows | 5 | 2097 | $211,380 |
| Subdivision | # Homes | Sq Ft | Sold Price |
| Summerwood | 8 | 4407 | $535,862 |
| Willow Bend | 10 | 3864 | $459,000 |
| Highland Lakes (OSD) | 38 | 3512 | $403,155 |
| Harbor Pointe | 12 | 3363 | $390,826 |
| North Orange | 7 | 3275 | $379,786 |
| Meadows of Cheshire | 9 | 2520 | $275,000 |
| Cheshire Crossing | 15 | 2253 | $251,100 |
| Dornoch | 9 | 2372 | $239,455 |
| Stratford Woods | 13 | 2141 | $208,700 |
| Subdivision | # Homes | Sq Ft | Sold Price |
| Old Stone | 4 | 2976 | $444,950 |
| Sanctuary | 3 | 3783 | $426,016 |
| Josephinum | 3 | 3138 | $382,666 |
| Worthingway | 8 | 2373 | $334,975 |
| Stilson | 10 | 2923 | $330,460 |
| Worthington Hills | 24 | 2626 | $318,358 |
| Olentangy Highlands | 10 | 2704 | $296,400 |
| Old Worthington | 13 | 1821 | $291,592 |
| Riverlea | 9 | 1926 | $282,766 |
| Lazelle Woods | 5 | 2887 | $269,500 |
| Kilbourne | 12 | 1852 | $253,867 |
| Brookside | 18 | 2230 | $236,491 |
| Worthington Estates | 26 | 1918 | $221,080 |
| Olde Sawmill (WSD) | 11 | 2042 | $207,472 |
| Subdivision | # Homes | Sq Ft | Sold Price |
| Medallion | 14 | 3924 | $446,564 |
| Havest Wind | 16 | 2945 | $395,133 |
| Highland Lakes (WSD) | 52 | 3048 | $337,593 |
| Shellbark | 3 | 3030 | $325,000 |
| Mariner’s Cove | 13 | 2923 | $299,000 |
| Eagle Trace | 10 | 3091 | $293,340 |
| Barrington Estates | 10 | 2597 | $270,630 |
| Heritage Estates | 10 | 2703 | $254,031 |
| Olde Mill | 3 | 2451 | $247,066 |
| Sherbrook | 22 | 2343 | $239,211 |
| Subdivision | # Homes | Sq Ft | Sold Price |
| Scioto Estates | 1 | 2938 | $455,000 |
| Ballantrae | 37 | 3615 | $449,740 |
| Heritage Lakes | 9 | 3362 | $398,666 |
| Stonewyck Manor | 5 | 3925 | $436,000 |
| Scioto Run | 8 | 2740 | $302,475 |
| Lakewood | 10 | 2984 | $287,170 |
| Hoffman Farms | 34 | 2877 | $289,947 |
| Vill at Homestead | 2 | 2461 | $278,000 |
| Britton Farms | 11 | 2722 | $278,672 |
| River Park | 4 | 2653 | $263,203 |
| River Landings | 11 | 2447 | $259,354 |
| Kendall Ridge | 8 | 2044 | $244,193 |
| Vill at Thornapple | 11 | 2626 | $240,000 |
| River Crossing | 2 | 2360 | $238,500 |
| River Place | 8 | 2352 | $232,118 |
| Heritage Creek | 8 | 2543 | $223,556 |
| Westbriar | 2 | 2060 | $223,250 |
| Brookfield Village | 14 | 2247 | $204,621 |
| Saddlebrook | 17 | 1972 | $204,594 |
| Subdivision | # Homes | Sq Ft | Sold Price |
| Lambton Park | 5 | 5560 | $1,394,032 |
| Waterston | 3 | 6723 | $1,152,304 |
| Pembrooke | 4 | 5050 | $868,250 |
| New Albany CC | 8 | 5504 | $798,875 |
| The Crescent | 4 | 4839 | $712,687 |
| Tidewater | 2 | 4452 | $697,500 |
| Brandon | 11 | 4369 | $655,906 |
| Fenway | 4 | 3881 | $550,552 |
| Pickett Place | 3 | 3694 | $497,041 |
| Planters Grove | 10 | 3682 | $469,150 |
| New Albany Links | 25 | 3136 | $346,503 |
| Hampsted | 43 | 3223 | $342,280 |
| The Preserve | 22 | 2548 | $267,418 |
| Albany Park | 7 | 2155 | $232,314 |
| Preston Common | 8 | 2447 | $223,112 |
| Subdivision | # Homes | Sq Ft | Sold Price |
| Shelbourne Forest | 13 | 2881 | $196,132 |
| Millbrook | 1 | 1813 | $190,380 |
| Troy Farms | 11 | 2029 | $175,262 |
| Carson Farms | 11 | 1860 | $170,368 |
| Locust Curve | 12 | 2066 | $165,633 |
| Lexington Glen | 7 | 2185 | $162,157 |
| Wesleyan Woods | 2 | 2091 | $157,450 |
| Kensington Place | 18 | 1845 | $155,597 |
| Nottingham | 7 | 1454 | $147,850 |
| Oakhurst | 1 | 2170 | $147,500 |
| Lantern Chase | 20 | 1846 | $147,025 |
Elaine Reese
614-825-8860Real Living HER
20 responses so far ↓
dblowers // February 19, 2008 at 4:33 pm
I’d be very curious to see how the home sales sale prices have trended month over month for the different subdivisions. Is that available anywhere you know of?
Thanks
elainereese // February 19, 2008 at 8:07 pm
It’s quite time-consuming to calculate this list each month and I don’t save the data from the previous month. If you have a particular subdivision that you’re interested in, email me with your request and which months or quarters you would like to see the monthly or quarterly data for. I can calculate the data just for you.
See the email link at the top of the right sidebar.
Thanks for stopping by.
Anonymous // February 29, 2008 at 7:21 pm
For Hilliard, you might want to add Brookfield Village. It is a large subdivision with listings typically between $195K - $260K.
elainereese // February 29, 2008 at 11:11 pm
Anonymous: thanks for your input. I just added Brookfield Village to the Hilliard chart.
Anonymous // March 21, 2008 at 3:39 pm
Can you add Thornapple Highlands in the Hilliard list? It’s a neighboring subdivision of Villa at Thornapple (already on your list).
Thanks
elainereese // March 21, 2008 at 5:31 pm
Anonymous #2:
I checked the data for Thornapple Highlands. Since Sept, 2007 there were 2 homes sold, with an average size of 1736 sq ft, priced at an average of $102/sq ft, with an average price of $177,450.
Hope that helps.
Anonymous // April 2, 2008 at 9:30 pm
Elaine, I enjoy your website. It is interesting to see these numbers and definitely the kind of tool someone house-shopping would be interested in..
Different Hilliard poster here
(I’m the one who mentioned Brookfield Village, not the one who mentioned Thornapple Highlands). Other good-sized Hilliard subdivisions include Westbrooke and Western Lakes. I think Westbriar, Hyde Park and Heritage Creek are pretty decent-sized, too. I know your list for Hilliard is already pretty big, but those may/may not be worth considering adding to your list.
Question for you… Do your “Hoffman Farms” numbers include those homes in the “Estates at Hoffman Farms”? The reason I ask is that sometimes they are considered separate subdivisions (by Franklin County, for instance), so I was curious if the sales numbers for Hoffman Farms included Estates at HF as well.
elainereese // April 2, 2008 at 10:59 pm
Anonymous - I’m going to have trouble keeping you “anonymous” people apart.
When I rerun the numbers for March, I’ll look into the subdivisions you suggest to see if enough homes have sold to add them to the list. I’ll likely be doing that update this weekend.
Regarding Hoffman Farms, yes, I lump them all together just to keep the list more manageable. Also, some listing agents aren’t always specific with their entry into the subdivision box in the MLS, so I do a blanket search for just the Hoffman Farms name.
Anonymous // April 3, 2008 at 4:06 pm
Thanks for your reply!
One last comment/suggestion from the Hilliard anon #1…
There is a new subdivision (3-4 yrs old) named “Village at Homestead” that is between and adjacent to Hoffman Farms/Estates at HF. Prices seem to range approximately 275-425K and several (7 or 8?) homes are currently on the market. This sub may/may not be worth adding or combining with Hoffman Farms/Estates at HF.
elainereese // April 5, 2008 at 6:48 pm
To the “anonymous” Hilliard folks:
I added the requested neighborhoods except for …
* Brookfield Village - 1 home sold for $137K.
* Thornapple Highlands - no homes sold
Anonymous // April 6, 2008 at 9:57 am
Elaine, Thanks, so much again.
I see that you deleted Brookfield Village due to the low volume/house price in the Jan-Mar timeframe. That makes sense. That price is definitely atypical of Brookfield Village. I think when you initially added it for Sep-Feb, the avg. price was somewhere around $225-$230K.
Any chance that you could possibly add it in the future, if/when more normal activity/selling prices occur?
elainereese // April 6, 2008 at 10:56 am
Anonymous: Regarding Brookfield, I’ve kept it in my search list so we’ll see how it does for the April report. Like other areas, I think a foreclosure probably is affecting the data.
Sales for Brookfield for the 2007 year was:
14 homes sold at an average price of $224 with an average size of 2307 sq ft.
Tom // May 16, 2008 at 8:04 am
Do you collect data for the RAVINES AT
WORTHINGTON SEC 2 ? 43085 zip in Worthington schools
(off Oakmeadows Drive)
elainereese // May 16, 2008 at 9:59 am
Tom, I just checked for sales for the Ravines at WO. Only one home has sold since January. It sold for $147,500 for 1532 sq ft.
Because the average sold prices for the suburbs above is over $200K, I’ve decided to use that as the bottom price for the list simply to keep the list from getting longer than it already is. The exception being all the subdivisions in northwest Delaware which are included only to have some info for that “affordable” city.
Anonymous // July 2, 2008 at 4:12 pm
Do you have the number of homes available for sale in each subdivision? Lots?
Elaine Reese // July 2, 2008 at 4:47 pm
Anonymous: That would be an ever-changing number!!!!
If you want to see what is for sale for specific subdivisions, I suggest setting up a “Saved Search” on Real Living HER’s web site.
Simply click on the red box on the sidebar above that says, “Search All MLS Listings”. That will take you to HER’s web site. Once there, you can set up your own Saved Search using the Advance search criteria which can be done by subdivision. Then you will get automatic emails when there are changes to any active listings.
I have several clients or friends that have done this just because they want to track their neighborhood’s prices … or just be the first to know when a home is new to the market.
Terry // July 6, 2008 at 4:32 pm
Love the site, lots of good information. My wife and I are currently looking at starting a family and building a new house, we are currently in apartment living as we sold our previous home last year a lot sooner than we thought.
Here is the dilemma, building on a lot in Scioto Reserve in Buckeye Valley SD or a lot in Alum Crossing which is Olentangy. In the short run (first 5 years) it would actually be about $114 a month cheaper at the Alum Crossing development, however once factors expire/payoff (PMI, interest buy down), then the Scioto Reserve lot become less expensive in the long run. However, I am worried that building in a community (Scioto Reserve)dominated by Olentengy School homes, we would be committing “resale suicide” if we needed to sell this home to another family. Please advise if we should just assume the $114 difference as an “resale/appreciation insurance policy” at Alum Crossing or if we are over analyzing the situation and should reduce our payments by building on the Buckeye Valley lot. Based on the info I have read both school systems seem to be very good with Olentangy being marginally better. Ironically Olentangy was an average school system at best in 2000 when we built our first home in Liberty Lakes. So maybe Buckeye Valley will take off just as much in the long run?
Thanks!
Elaine Reese // July 6, 2008 at 9:54 pm
Well, Terry, wait just a moment while I check my crystal ball to see what the world will be like in 5 years!
There’s quite a bit of difference to the location of those 2 subdivisions. Aside from evaluating the school districts, it would seem that proximity to your employment would certainly also be a major consideration. With gas prices, any extra driving to work, could easily eliminate that $114 difference if that distance is an issue.
You also might compare property taxes. In general, Buckeye Valley rates are lower per $100K evaluation. You might want to check with the schools to see where new elementaries are being planned (since you plan to start a family) to see how close or far you will be to the school.
Since you’re doing such a thorough analysis, you might also visit the County Engineer’s web site to see what growth/expansion plans are for Old State and Section Line roads. Those plans could affect future value of surrounding homes.
Beyond all that, which area seems to offer the most benefits such as shopping, restaurants, entertainment, etc that you enjoy.
Good luck with your decision process. Thanks for the compliment on this site.
Michelle Paul // August 3, 2008 at 5:26 pm
I just happened to stumble upon this website by accident. I must say I am from Philadelphia, PA and we are getting robbed. The going price for these houses is a steal compared to where I live. They want double to actually live comfortably. The houses are beautiful and your website is awsome. If I ever decide to move to Ohio, I will definitely give you a call
Elaine Reese // August 3, 2008 at 6:37 pm
Michelle … glad you stumbled by! You live too close to NYC. In the ’90’s, I was offered a Marketing position in northern NJ. Very nice salary on paper, but not when C-O-L was calculated.
Leave a Comment